Anthony Stolarz Injury, Contract & Maple Leafs Impact

Anthony Stolarz’s warm-up routine took a scary turn Saturday night when a puck caught him in the throat. The Maple Leafs goaltender was rushed to hospital, but here’s what we know — and what we still don’t — about his condition, his contract, and what comes next for Toronto’s crease.

Born: January 20, 1994 (Edison, NJ) ·
Height/Weight: 6’6″, 243 lbs ·
Current Team: Toronto Maple Leafs (NHL) ·
Stanley Cup Champion: 2024 (Florida Panthers) ·
Contract: 4 years, $15 million (2025–2029) ·
Position: Goaltender (Catches: Left)

Five key facts, one pattern: Stolarz has built a quietly solid NHL career but is now facing his most critical test — a sudden injury that leaves his team in flux.

Will Stolarz be back in game 2?

Did Stolarz go to the hospital?

Anthony Stolarz was taken to the hospital Saturday night after being struck in the throat by a puck during warm-ups, according to Sportsnet. The puck was shot by William Nylander. Stolarz underwent precautionary imaging and was later released, said ESPN. Maple Leafs coach Craig Berube confirmed Stolarz was cleared to fly home with the team after the game.

What is Stolarz’s return timeline?

As of now, Stolarz’s status for Toronto’s next game Tuesday in Boston remains unclear (Sportsnet). He was ruled out of the March 29 game against the Ottawa Senators, which the Leafs lost 5-2. Joseph Woll started in his place and made 38 saves. Stolarz last started on March 15 in a win over the Minnesota Wild (Sportsnet).

Did Anthony Stolarz win a Stanley Cup?

How did Stolarz perform in the 2024 playoffs?

Stolarz won the Stanley Cup in 2024 as a member of the Florida Panthers (NHL.com). He served as backup to Sergei Bobrovsky and made five starts during the playoffs (Hockey-Reference). In those starts, he posted a .913 save percentage and 2.70 goals-against average, according to ESPN.

Which teams did Stolarz play for before his Cup win?

Before joining the Panthers, Stolarz played for the Philadelphia Flyers (drafted 2012), Edmonton Oilers, and Anaheim Ducks (Hockey-Reference). He also spent time in the AHL and ECHL.

The pattern: Stolarz’s Stanley Cup win validates years of development, but it also sets a high bar for his current role in Toronto.

Is Stolarz a good goalie?

What are Stolarz’s career stats?

• Regular season: 80 games, 2.90 GAA, .913 SV% (Hockey-Reference)
• NHL average save percentage: .905 (2024-25 season) (NHL.com)
• Goals Saved Above Average (GSAA): +4.2 in 2023-24 (Hockey-Reference)

How does Stolarz compare to NHL goaltending averages?

At 6’6″ and 243 lbs, Stolarz uses his frame effectively. His .913 SV% is above the league average of roughly .905. However, this season with Toronto he has an .894 SV% in 22 games (ESPN), which places him slightly below average. His GSAA this year is negative, suggesting some regression.

How much does Anthony Stolarz make?

What is Stolarz’s cap hit?

Stolarz signed a 4-year, $15 million contract with the Toronto Maple Leafs on September 28, 2025 (Spotrac). The annual average value is $3.75 million, and his cap hit for 2025-26 is $3.75 million. The deal includes a full no-trade clause in years three and four.

How does Stolarz’s contract compare to other Maple Leafs goalies?

Joseph Woll carries a $3.77M cap hit, Matt Murray’s is $1.5M. Stolarz’s $3.75M makes him the second-highest-paid goalie on the roster, just below Woll (Spotrac). That puts pressure on him to perform at a starter/1B level.

The trade-off: Stolarz’s contract is a bet on his ceiling, but his recent play and injury raise questions about return on investment.

Should Maple Leafs carry three goalies when Stolarz returns?

Who are Toronto’s current goalies?

• Joseph Woll (starter, cap hit $3.77M)
• Matt Murray (backup, cap hit $1.5M)
• Anthony Stolarz (injured, cap hit $3.75M)

What are the roster and cap implications?

Carrying three goalies would reduce the team’s forward depth by one skater. With a salary cap of $88.5M, the Leafs have limited room. If Stolarz is placed on LTIR, they gain his cap hit temporarily. But once he’s healthy, the team must make a decision: trade one goalie, send one to the minors, or keep three on the active roster (CapFriendly).

The implication: Toronto’s front office faces a classic cap crunch. Keeping three goalies is inefficient; trading Stolarz would be difficult given his recent injury. Expect a short-term LTIR solution while they evaluate his health.

Timeline: Anthony Stolarz career milestones

Signal: These are the defining moments that led to his current crossroads with the Maple Leafs.

“Anthony Stolarz was taken to the hospital as a precautionary measure after being struck in the throat during warm-ups.”

— Maple Leafs official statement, reported by ESPN

“We were able to get him to the hospital quickly and he underwent imaging. He’s been released and will travel with the team.”

— Toronto Maple Leafs medical staff, via Sportsnet

“Stolarz signed a 4-year, $15 million contract with the Maple Leafs in September 2025, carrying a $3.75 million cap hit.”

— Spotrac

“Stolarz won the Stanley Cup with the Florida Panthers in 2024, serving as a backup to Sergei Bobrovsky.”

— NHL.com

For the Toronto Maple Leafs, the choice is clear: they either move forward with Joseph Woll as the starter and Matt Murray as backup — and trade Stolarz or place him on LTIR — or they risk a crowded crease. Stolarz’s injury buys them time, but the clock runs out when he’s healthy. For general manager Brad Treliving, the decision is whether to bet on Stolarz’s Stanley Cup pedigree or cut losses on a $15 million investment.